Torque oscillations while sitting
30oct19
On 30oct19 around 10am the turret was moved
from lbw (285 deg) to alfa (26 deg). During the motion carlos
reported that the turret moving, stopping, and restaring.. a jerking
motion. A similar problem had been reported by felix a week earlier.
In that case the maintenance crew put a little more grease on the
rails.
When looking at the turret data for 30oct19 an
oscillation was seen in the torques (and the position) when the
turret was sitting at a fixed position. The position oscillation was
only a few a/d counts.
The plots show what was going on:
Turret status summary plots for
30oc19 0 to 16:00 hours (.ps) (.pdf)
- Page 1:
- top : turret position vs hour of day
- bottom: velocity command sent from cpu, and velocity
feedback
- the velocity feedback is read after the signal
conditioning board and before the amp.
- page 2-page9
- turret status bits vs hour of day.
- page 9 has the faults.
- the mot12spdGap error happens when the velocity
reported from the two motor amplifiers differs by more than
a defined amount.
- This may just be a calibration problem.
- page 10: motor torques for the master and slave motor.
torque oscillations
(.ps) (.pdf)
- page 1: status 0 to 16 hours
- top: turret position
- 2nd motor torques. black master, red slave.
- 3rd; motor1,2 speed gap error.
- This happens most times the turret moves (except 6:55am)
- 4th: motor speeds. master and slave. This shows when the
turret moved.
- bottom: master speed= slave speed.
- This shows the speed different between the 2 motors as
read back from the amplifiers.
- Page 2: blowup 8 to 10:30 am
- The position move around 10:00 was when the turret was
jerking (at least someone was there to see it.. it may have
also occurred at other times).
- You can see the torque oscillation 9-10am
- There is a speed gap error for most of the 10am move.
- Page 3: 9.3 to 9.4 hours. turret sitting at lbw
- The position is oscillating by 1 a/d level (about 2
millidegrees)
- the motor torques are oscillating because the turret is
moving (by only 1 count).
- the torques are getting up to about 8 foot-lbs (in master)
- Page 4: the position torques at 10:00 when the floor was
jerking.
- Page 5: 9.3 to 9.95 hours.. turret sitting at lbw.
- Top: position oscillation with drift
- 2nd : motor torque
- bottom: spectrum of the torque oscillations
- I used 9.3 to 9.95 hours
- the period is .0136 hz .. or about 73 second period
(see purple lines in frame 1,2)
Az, za position during torque
oscillations (.ps) (.pdf)
- I've plotted 3.0 to 5.0 hours. the turret was sitting at 26
degrees (alfa in focus)
- There are oscillation at 3.25 to 3.5 and 4.4 to 4.7 hours.
- this corresponds to za 14-13 deg and za 5-6 degrees.
- The turret is level at za=10 degrees.
- You might expect things to be unbalanced at the highest (20
deg) or lowest (1-2) degrees.
- We are seeing oscillations in intermediate za .. so it may
not be associated with the floor tilt.
Summary:
- When the turret is commanded to sit at a position, the
position and torque oscillate with a period of about 73
seconds.
- The position is only moving by about 1 or 2 a/d counts
- the torque (in master or slave) can be changing by up to 8
ft-lbs.
- This is coming from the PI loop.
- I wonder if the amplitude of the torques needed for the
motion is because the friction (stiction) might be
large.
- It may also be a problem in the anti backlash board
adjustments
- It might be interesting to see if the amplitude of the torque
is a function of where it is sitting?
- this might tell us something about bad spots on the rail
- unfortunately we normally only sit at discrete locations
(where the receiver is that we are using).
processing: x101/191030/tur_torque_osc_sitting.pro
up to turret page
home_~phil